When self-checkout machines first emerged in supermarkets, they were heralded as the future of shopping—promising swift queues, reduced staff numbers, and a seamless customer experience. Fast forward to today, and that initial excitement has dimmed. Both consumers and retailers are confronting the reality that the promise of those sleek touchscreen kiosks comes with significant complications.
A money-saving strategy that backfired
The rationale seemed straightforward: instead of multiple cashiers, have one employee oversee a cluster of self-checkout machines. However, Christopher Andrews, an associate professor of sociology at Drew University in New Jersey, reveals a different story. In an interview with the BBC, he noted that many retailers are realising too late that rather than saving money, they are incurring losses.
The financial setbacks are leading major players in the retail sector to reassess their strategies. In the United States, chains like Target, Walmart, and discount leader Dollar General are reducing their reliance on self-checkout. Across the pond, British supermarket Booths has opted to eliminate nearly all self-checkout kiosks entirely.
The key issues? Slowdowns, technical failures, and an unpredicted surge in theft.
Discount retailers admit a misstep in automation reliance
Perhaps the most notable admission came from Dollar General CEO Todd Vasos, who acknowledged to investors, “We relied too heavily on self-checkout in our stores.”
In recent times, it has been common to walk into a Dollar General and find just a couple of staff members manning the entire store, while most customers were directed towards self-checkout lanes. However, the retailer now intends to boost staffing levels, particularly at manned checkout points.
Why this change? Internal analytics have reportedly indicated that stores overly dependent on self-checkout experience higher-than-average shrink—a term that encompasses losses stemming from theft, errors, or inventory mismanagement.
Customer enthusiasm dwindled upon trial
Initially, shoppers were optimistic about self-checkout. A 2021 survey of 1,000 Americans found that 60% of respondents preferred self-checkout to traditional, staffed lanes, drawn in by the allure of speed, independence, and the absence of obligatory chit-chat.
However, the same study revealed a significant drawback—67% of users had encountered issues with the technology. We’ve all been there:
• the scanner refuses to register an item
• the machine alerts that the bagging area “has an unexpected item”
• the system freezes and prompts for an employee’s assistance.
Amit Kumar, a professor of marketing and psychology at the University of Texas, aptly stated, “If we try self-checkout and realise we’re not benefitting from it, we eventually stop using it.”
In essence, shoppers are unlikely to stick with a system that introduces more hassle than it alleviates.
The enduring presence of self-checkout machines
Despite the frustrations, it’s unlikely that self-checkouts will disappear entirely. Retailers have invested significant resources into the necessary hardware, software, training, and store layouts associated with self-checkout systems. Those sunk costs mean many retailers will maintain these machines, but they’re reassessing their dependence on them.
The trend emerging is one of choice: customers can select either a human cashier or a digital kiosk, based on their preferences. For supermarkets, this balance allows them to manage costs while avoiding complete reliance on a system that has proven to be less reliable than anticipated.
The bottom line: a hybrid future for retail
Self-checkout was meant to revolutionise the retail experience. Instead, it has become a cautionary tale regarding the perils of over-automating essential human tasks. With increasing theft, frustrated shoppers, and growing financial losses, retailers are learning a vital lesson: efficiency isn’t solely about technology—it’s fundamentally about people.
The next evolution in retail won’t be entirely robotic or entirely human. It will likely be a blend, allowing shoppers to choose the experience that meets their needs. And as many retailers have come to realise, sometimes the most efficient “technology” is still a skilled cashier who knows precisely what they’re doing.







